Hawaiian fish are once again in jeopardy. Appeal for support.

In the tranquil waters of Hawaii, a contentious battle rages over the collection of marine fish species. It’s a struggle that pits environmental concerns against economic interests, with the fate of Hawaiian aquatic ecosystems hanging in the balance. At the heart of this conflict lies the question of whether fish collection can be conducted sustainably, preserving both the delicate marine ecosystem and the livelihoods of those who depend on it.

The saga began around a year ago when Hawaiian Senate Bill 505, which sought to legalise the collection of eight marine fish species, was voted down. However, the defeat of the bill did not spell the end of the debate. Individual collection companies were still required to navigate a complex permitting process overseen by the Department of Land and Natural Resources. Furthermore, a court order mandated an exhaustive environmental impact evaluation before permits could be issued.

Now, after months of analysis, the environmental impact assessment is complete, paving the way for the next phase of the permitting process. An initial meeting is scheduled for April 12th, where the Division of Aquatic Resources will present its findings to the Department of Land and Natural Resources Board. If all goes well, this meeting could mark the beginning of a new chapter for the Hawaiian fish collection industry.

However, the road ahead is fraught with challenges. Radical groups advocating for a fishery ban have once again raised their voices, calling for the closure of marine fish collection in Hawaiian waters. This sets the stage for a final showdown, where the fate of the industry will be decided once and for all.

At this critical juncture, individuals have a vital role to play in shaping the outcome. By voicing their support for science-based conservation efforts, they can help ensure the sustainable management of Hawaii’s marine resources. One way to do this is by emailing their support for the issuance of collection permits to the Department of Land and Natural Resources.

But what does science say about the impact of fish collection on Hawaiian marine ecosystems? According to the findings of the environmental impact assessment, several key species have shown remarkable resilience in the face of collection activities. The population of Yellow Tangs, for example, has increased by 150% from 1999 to 2018, with similar trends observed for other species like Kole Tangs. These population gains have occurred despite active collection, suggesting that well-managed harvesting practices can coexist with healthy fish populations.

Public opinion polls also provide valuable insights into the attitudes of Hawaiians towards fish collection. Overwhelmingly, Hawaiians support the sustainable use of their natural resources, with 96% expressing approval for such practices. Moreover, a significant majority believes that decisions regarding resource management should be based on scientific evidence rather than the opinions of special interest groups.

These findings underscore the importance of adopting a science-based approach to conservation. By leveraging data-driven decision-making, policymakers can strike a balance between conservation and economic development, ensuring the long-term viability of Hawaii’s marine ecosystems.

Indeed, the economic stakes are high. The domestic United States saltwater aquarium trade, which relies heavily on Hawaiian fish species, is valued at $5.12 billion. Many Hawaiian fish represent top sellers in this lucrative market, providing a crucial source of revenue for the local economy. By supporting sustainable fish collection, Hawaiians can safeguard this vital economic lifeline while also preserving their natural heritage for future generations.

In the face of mounting pressure from environmental activists, it’s essential to separate fact from fiction. Contrary to claims of irreversible harm, scientific evidence suggests that well-managed fish collection can be conducted without detriment to marine ecosystems. Population studies indicate robust growth rates for key species, while public opinion polls reveal broad support for responsible resource management.

As the April 12th meeting approaches, the stakes could not be higher. The decisions made in the coming weeks will shape the future of Hawaii’s marine fish collection industry for years to come. By standing together and advocating for science-based conservation, we can ensure that Hawaii’s rich aquatic biodiversity continues to thrive for generations to come.

Do your part! 

Email the following –  blnr.testimony@hawaii.gov 

Include “Agenda Item F2 and F3” in the subject. Simply write “I oppose banning the aquarium fishery, and I support managing resources by science as provided by DAR.” Followed by your name.